Will Tesla's Stock Boom Come to a Screeching Halt? Insights from a Leading Analyst

Will Tesla's Stock Boom Come to a Screeching Halt? Insights from a Leading Analyst

Will Tesla's Stock Boom Come to a Screeching Halt? Insights from a Leading Analyst

Investments Jun 2, 2025

As one of the most sensational stocks of the decade, Tesla (TSLA) has witnessed an astronomical rise, capturing the imagination of investors worldwide. However, this golden era might be nearing its twilight, as seasoned investment analysts warn of potential headwinds looming on the horizon.

Concerns Raised by Gary Black

Gary Black, Managing Partner at The Future Fund, has effectively sounded alarm bells regarding Tesla’s growth trajectory and valuation. As mentioned in a compelling analysis, Finbold, Black moves away from Tesla stocks, citing concerns about its valuation and future growth potential, steering his investments towards stronger fundamentals.

The Valuation Puzzle

One cannot ignore Tesla’s current forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio standing at a daunting 180x for the year 2025. Black emphasizes that maintaining such a P/E ratio, especially for a $1 trillion company, is challenging without extraordinary growth. Projected forward P/E ratios drop to 120x by 2026 and 45x by 2029, indicating an imbalance.

These figures feed into Black’s apprehensions about Tesla’s capacity to sustain its earnings growth, particularly as Wall Street revises its earnings projections, slashing them by up to 40%.

Tesla’s Future Markets

Tesla’s innovation in areas such as Robotaxis and the Optimus humanoid robot signifies its plunge into futuristic markets. Black argues that as Tesla ventures into these areas, its stock’s valuation may have already exceeded reasonable growth upsides.

According to Finbold, these moves are anticipated to integrate into Tesla’s growth metrics by 2029, potentially diminishing forward growth rates.

Retreating Stock Performance

The market seems to be responding already, with Tesla stock retracing by over 3% in the last session, closing at $346.46 and a year-to-date decline of almost 9%. Despite backlash related to CEO Elon Musk’s controversial political views and decreasing sales, the stock’s dip could indeed be a precursor to a more extensive retraction.

The Road Ahead for Tesla

While the challenges are undeniably formidable, the withdrawal of Elon Musk from a governmental advisory role may resurrect some investor confidence. However, the fundamental cracks pointed out by experts like Gary Black remind us that an unwavering focus on intrinsic value may be crucial for investors going forward.

Is this the dawn of a new era for Tesla investors, or merely a brief pause in an otherwise prolific journey? Only time will tell.

Tags